my grade
-/5

average
3.09/5

The Sparrow

number of reviews: 0number of reviews: 0number of reviews: 0number of reviews: 1number of reviews: 7number of reviews: 7number of reviews: 15number of reviews: 3number of reviews: 4number of reviews: 3

Cinemasie's opinions

5 reviews: 3/5

your opinions

34 reviews: 3.1/5



Anel 4
Elise 2
François 3.25
Ordell Robbie 3 The Umbrellas of Hong Kong
Xavier Chanoine 2.75
order by grades | date | reviewer    lengths: any length medium and long only long only


The Umbrellas of Hong Kong

In its spirit, Johnnie TO's Sparrow is closer to the assumed glamour superficiality of Yesterday Once More than to the movies that established TO's leadership on HK post-1997 genre cinema. But it achieves better its small goals than this film. As much as Exiled was a tribute to John WOO, PECKINPAH and Spaghetti western, Sparrow pays tribute to GODARD, DEMY and 50's Hollywood cinema. The jazz-like score and the coolness of the character played by Simon YAM send us back to Breatheless. And of course Kelly LAM and Simon YAM are no Cary GRANT/Grace KELLY but they act with a sense of glamour the movie's situations allows them to bring. As a consequence, the first half of the movie is a heaven for those who can appreciate assumed coolness as long as it's shot with style, a thing TO does have as a director. But after the characters' installation comes the trouble in paradise: TO doesn't know which story to tell and the humour reminds us of the heaviness of HK bad comedies. In its end, the movie finds again a little bit of grace, despite the fact that the final 'tribute to DEMY' action sequence doesn' equal the greatness of TO's action scenes in The Mission, PTU or Exiled. But Sparrow has enough charm to make forget it isn't vintage TO...

09 September 2008
by Ordell Robbie


buy it
info
actions
plus